Well the moment Dhoni lost the 3rd and final Super8 games against Sri Lanka he came out with a statement that has found support from the whole of the cricket loving nation and surprisingly from the BCCCI as well. And the only reason the statement got this overwhelming support was that we find it very convenient to find an excuse rather than accept a lack of skill, ability and commitment.
Well I believe if we look at the recent chain of events more objectively we would be able to give ourselves sufficient reasons to believe that IPL and its after match parties were little (if at all) to be held responsible for the disappointing Indian performance.
- Soon after the so called mentally and physically exhausting season of IPL III Indian teams lands in the Carribiean island of St. Lucia, and starts off with a comprehensive win over minnows Afghanistan. No evident signs of players’ weariness and even the historically most party prone “Yuvraj Singh” looked comfortable.
- Next we are up against the strong SA squad and we ride home on the back of a superb innings by Suresh Raina who ideally should have been the toast of all those IPL parties given the prolific run he had in this year’s IPL. No evident signs of player fatigue mental or physical.
- Now India runs into a quality Australian side that have the advantage of a bouncy Barbados wicket, 2 or 3 140+ pacers and the “obvious” knowledge of Indian lineups inability to handle fast paced bouncers. Following an average or probably a below average bowling performance comes a truly shameful batting display. And at the end of the match Dhoni knows and admits the right reason for the defeat.
- Now the scenario has changed the world knows that it’s quite easy to bounce India out on the Barbados wicket if you have some 140+ stuff. And surprisingly the West Indies attack for a change manages to stick to the plan, after the superb effort from Chris Gayle had taken care of the batting department. But even now the 2nd most party prone Indian player Harbhajan is tying up the batsman with some great spin bowling right at the start inspite of the field restrictions.
- Then with the venue shifting back to the less bouncy St. Lucia pitch, Indian team as expected recovers from the mentally and physically exhausting IPL schedule and put up a fighting(almost winning) effort against the Sri Lankan. Probably the reason for losing the close finish would be the lack of motivation once Sri Lanka had gone past the 143 mark that was crucial in the NRR equation. And notice have the so far very effective Harbhajan goes for runs against the Sri Lankan team packed with good players of spin.
- Now having lost all 3 of the Super 8 matches Dhoni, very unlike him,comes up with this excuse. I say unlike him because he is probably one of the most sensible, humble and communicative captain India has seen in years (atleast since I have followed cricket).
Now if we as a cricketing nation cannot see an obvious trend in what’s happening then either we don’t understand cricket or we feel it’s more honorable to find excuses for bad performance rather than admitting the obvious lack of ability.
The results clearly showed 2 crystal clear facts hard to be missed:
- The Indian batsman find it really difficult to score off rising fast deliveries directed at their bodies, especially when the pitch is assisting the pace and bounce. They had developed a solution to the problem in longer versions of the game by swaying or ducking bouncers but cannot afford to do so in 20-20 especially when chasing 170+ scores.
- Harbhajan Singh and other spinners could bowl beautifully against everyone except Sri Lankans and Yuvraj Singh could score against South Africans, so what mattered way more than IPL fatigue (if at all) were the strengths and weaknesses of the opposition.
By way of this article what I do not intend to do is claim that Dhoni’s statement about the fatigue that IPL and the parties caused is completely false or baseless, but just clarify that it can no way be the primary reason for India’s dismal performance.
What really need to change is not the IPL but the level of the domestic cricket and the quality of the domestic pitches which should encourage raw pace bowling and exposes batsman to the need off cutting and pulling rather than mere driving down the ground with those heavy willows.
And in fact the very IPL we are blaming is the providing a great exposure and compensating for the low quality of domestic cricket. Agreed it takes a toll but at the same time it allows many youngsters a chance to face the Bonds, Taits, Steyns and Nannes of the world and realize at an early stage what they need to improve in their batting.
Some of us might like to shout back that we did beat Australia in Australia on those bouncy pitches but do remember they were not T20 and then we had a special man called Sachin in the team who could score off Bret lee’s bouncer by effortlessly lifting them way over wicket keeper’s head.
To Dhoni and team defense I do admit that IPL might have been a reason for the poor show of the team but I find it unacceptable as the most important reason that should grab all the national headlines. And the more recent statements asking for Dhoni’s removal as captain and suggesting Sehwag as replacement are even more ludicrous as Dhoni has probably been the most intelligent, calm under pressure cricketer who has the team skill to get the best out of both the seniors and the juniors in the team.
And I would have loved to agree with Gavaskar’s recent statement suggesting Indian team should practice short pitched stuff at NCA but who would be bowling it. Either Indian bowlers who barely crank mid 130’s or bowling machines which are so very predictable about the bounce they can extract from a particular length. Facing a human opposition who can crank mid 140s and vary the amount of shoulder put in every delivery is a totally different ball game and that skill can only be acquired by injecting some pace and bounce in Indian wickets where these players grow up playing.





